Which food is better: "Proplan" or "Royal Canin"? Composition, quality and recommendations of veterinarians

2024 Author: Priscilla Miln | [email protected]. Last modified: 2024-01-07 12:45

Pet nutrition is the main concern of the owner. The variety of dry food is great, their quality is different, as well as the price category. What to choose? Pay attention to super-premium brands. Dry food "Proplan" or "Royal Canin", according to manufacturers, is one of them.

Where is it produced?

What will the owner of the animal pay attention to when choosing food for him? Someone looks at the price, others look at the bright packaging, while the majority look at the composition and the manufacturer.

Russian food is considered to be of poor quality, unlike foreign ones. Which food is better - "Proplan" or "Royal Canin", if you focus on the manufacturer? According to experts:

1. Pro Plan is manufactured by the American company Purina. Factories are located in France, Italy and Russia.
2. Royal Canin - French food. Production plants are located in Poland, France and Russia.

Pro Plan food composition

What to choose for a pet: the American company "Purina" ("Proplan") or "Royal Canin" of French production? We suggest that you familiarize yourself with the composition of Pro Plan in detail, as an example, food for adult cats is taken:

1. The first word on the package is "chicken". The percentage of its component is 21.
2. Wheat is second, dry bird protein is third.
3. Rice and wheat gluten take the fourth and fifth lines.

Now more about each product that is part of the feed in question.

Detailed analysis of the composition

Chicken is a dietary product useful for cat he alth. Only the question arises: what is hidden under this word? According to American standards, chicken refers to offal, skin, bones and feathers. Therefore, it remains a mystery what is in the Pro Plan feed: real meat or industrial waste. Veterinarians note that the amount of chicken is negligible, not up to super-premium food.

Now about wheat, its percentage is not specified. Wheat is a source of carbohydrates, but its place in the feed composition is alarming. The cat is a predator, the first three lines in dry food should be occupied by meat products. Wheat is not one of them, it is a cheap and satisfying filler. For economy-class products, it is suitable, but for food that claims to be super-premium, it is hardly.

Dry bird protein contains proteins. AgainHowever, its quantity in the composition is not indicated. Rice is another source of carbohydrates. Too many carbohydrates for a complete cat diet. The manufacturer replaced the natural meat component with them.

Wheat gluten contains vegetable protein. The key word is vegetable, we take this into account. Based on the foregoing, it is concluded that the food does not correspond to a super-premium product. It contains too many vegetable proteins and carbohydrates. Veterinarians rarely recommend a product to cat owners.

Let's analyze the composition of French food to find out which is better: "Proplan" or "Royal Canin".

Royal Canin ingredients

"Royal Canin" is cheaper than "Pro Plan", it can be purchased by almost anyone. There are often discounts on products in large pet stores, and you just want to take a couple of packages while the promotion is going on. Before buying food, study its composition:

1. The first place is occupied by vegetable protein isolate. The manufacturer claims these proteins are highly digestible and are specially selected for food production.
2. The second line reports the presence of dehydrated (dried) poultry proteins.
3. Rice is number three, wheat is fourth.
4. Animal fats close the list.

Composition details

Is Royal Canin better than Proplan? Judging by the composition of the first - worsefactor of. Let's see why French products are so bad. Can vegetable proteins be in the first place in a good feed? Someone will say that they are a source of protein. Animal protein is ideal for cat food, vegetable protein is not. Not only is it at the heart of the product, but also the quantity is hidden.

Dried proteins from poultry meat. Where is the definition of its type? A bird can mean a chicken, a hazel grouse or a crow. The manufacturer kept silent about the species of the bird. As well as about the quantitative component of the declared proteins. According to veterinarians, this is a significant lack of food.

Rice and wheat are sources of carbohydrates, it is written above. Wheat is a cheap product, but satisfying. For products that are positioned as elite, such a filler is not suitable.

The cat receives the essential fatty acids from the appropriate component of the feed. Animal fats are on the fifth line, they raise all the same questions: what is the percentage component? What animals are we talking about? There is no answer, the manufacturer carefully hides information about this.

Which is better: Proplan or Royal Canin? Both foods are bad, but if there is no other choice, then the American products are better.

Price category

Both brands are quite expensive, for such a price you can get the best food. Consider the cost of the products under study:

1. Royal Canin, pack of 10 kg, will cost the buyer from 4,500 to 5,000 rubles, depending on the regionresidence.
2. Pro Plan for cats costs almost the same: from 4,800 to 5,200 rubles. Bag weight - 10 kg.

Pro Plan Benefits

Which food is better - "Proplan" or "Royal Canin", we found out. Both brands are of poor quality, although they are expensive and are considered super premium products.

Main Pro Plan Pros:

1. In the first place - the chicken component.
2. Various choice.
3. No problem with purchasing from regular and online pet stores.

Disadvantages of Pro Plan

Cat food "Proplan" has significant drawbacks. The main one is the composition of the product. In addition, the following are considered minuses:

1. Overpriced. The cost does not match the quality of the goods.
2. The amount of this or that product contained in the feed is not indicated.
3. Chicken is an allergen.

Pros of Royal Canin

We researched which food is better - "Proplan" or "Royal Canin". With the advantages and disadvantages of the first figured out. As for the second, its advantage is in a rich assortment. Manufacturer offers food for:

• kittens and lactating cats;
• adult stay-at-home animals;
• active cats;
• products are made taking into account the needs of a particular breed;
• there is a veterinary (medical) series of feed;
• you can buy food for neutered cats and neutered cats.

Cons of the product "Royal Canin"

Its composition is the biggest minus. As with the Pro Plan, the price is too high and the quality is low. The presence of flavoring additives is another significant drawback of Royal Canin food. Therefore, it is worth thinking before adding the product to the basket.

Comparative characteristics

We found out which food is better: "Proplan" or "Royal Canin". If we conduct a comparative product description, the conclusions are as follows:

1. Pro Plan contains chicken, which significantly outperforms the French competitor.
2. There are no flavorings in American food.
3. Proplan contains a protein component.

Comparison of Proplan and Royal Canin draws clear advantages of the former.

Reviews

Pet owners are divided into two camps. Some are delighted with the food in question, the second are shocked.

Here's what they say about "Proplan":

1. Cats eat with pleasure.
2. Gives animals rich coloration.
3. Waste products are minimal, almost odorless.
4. Other felines refuse food.
5. Causes allergic reactions.

Royal Canin reviews look like this:

1. Fair enough food.
2. Cats eat them up.
3. Many pets ask for supplements, the food is delicious for them.
4. Owners point out bad smell coming from products.
5. Some talk about small granules that make pets uncomfortable.
6. Cat colors are changing for the worse.
7. There is a lot of excrement, but there is no particularly strong smell.

Summing up

Having considered the composition of feed, their advantages and disadvantages, we boldly declare:

1. Poor quality product, far from super premium.
2. The price category is unreasonably high, overpaying for wheat, vegetable proteins and rice is a thankless task.
3. Judging by the reviews, the owners prefer the American food Pro Plan. And this despite the fact that most doctors of veterinary clinics recommend Royal Canin.

Conclusion

Focus on our review and reviews of the owners or not - the decision is up to the readers. Sometimes it’s worth buying food and making sure of its quality yourself, there is a phrase: you won’t know until you try it yourself.

Experienced veterinarians advise, when choosing between the considered feeds and the holistic class, give preference to the latter. They are expensive and the quality is excellent. Experts note that there are no bad reviews about holistic feeds.